Residents used a special process to stop unwanted mid-rise and multiplex development in their neighbourhoods.
This CBC News article, published on September 23, 2024, covers the Lake Bonavista residents' initiative to use restrictive covenants as a means to prevent multi-family developments in their neighborhood, following Calgary's approval of blanket rezoning policies. The article, shown below, discusses the legal nature of restrictive covenants, their attachment to land titles, and the community's goals in implementing them.
Text of Article
Another Calgary community turns to restrictive covenants with blanket rezoning in effect
The day Calgary city council approved its contentious blanket rezoning policy — which allows for different housing types, like duplexes and row houses to be built in all residential areas — Lake Bonavista residents began planning ahead.
That spring day, a group of homeowners in southeast Calgary held their first meeting about protecting their homes and community through restrictive covenants. They are legal contracts between homeowners that can prevent the construction of certain types of buildings. The covenants are attached to land titles, meaning they stay in place even when the property owners change.
They're also known to be challenging to remove.
What the heck are 'restrictive covenants' and how do they affect Calgary's housing situation? In Lake Bonavista, the goal is to legally prevent developers from tearing down single-family homes for multi-family developments, though residents have agreed to allow secondary suites in basements and garages.
"I think a lot of people are very uneasy about what's happening in the community," said Karen Robinson, a volunteer for the committee running the Lake Bonavista restrictive covenant initiative.
"I think it's going to be very disruptive to the fabric of the community and just not give people that comfort and peace of mind about knowing what their street is going to look like."
Robinson says she hopes at least 60 per cent of the community signs on so they can prevent "land assemblies" — where developers purchase multiple lots side-by-side to build larger developments — and remain a single-family community with wide streets, mature trees and large yards.
It isn't just happening in Lake Bonavista. Many Calgary communities have historic restrictive covenants in place, and a number of other Calgary communities are turning to the idea now that Calgary's blanket rezoning bylaw is in effect.
Curtis Marble, the lawyer representing Lake Bonavista residents, said 15 to 20 per cent of the community has agreed to get the restrictive covenant registered to their land titles.
According to the initiative's website, it costs $500 per household to get the covenant registered. Marble's team is getting those covenants finalized in batches, with roughly 70 households officially registered, he said. He said restrictive covenants are more common in Calgary than people think — but often people don't realize it's on their land title because, in most cases, there wasn't any reason to enforce them in court until recently.
"Given that the city's zoning laws were, until recently, in many of those neighbourhoods [consistent] with what the restrictive covenant was saying, it simply wasn't necessary to go to court," said Marble, a partner with Carbert Waite LLP.
That's changing, and so too is the nature of Marble's work. He's been litigating restrictive covenants for roughly five years. But now, his team is also working to draft new restrictive covenants for communities like Lake Bonavista.
"We were not doing that work prior to the city proposing and then passing the new bylaw," he said.
Marble is also working with Chinook Park, Kelvin Grove and Eagle Ridge on their restrictive covenant initiative, among other communities in the city. He predicts the covenants are going to become more common as time goes on. Residents in Rideau-Roxboro can attest to that. Many properties in that community have had restrictive covenants in place for decades, but now there's a new push to get the remaining homes on board.
"In our initiative to talk to our neighbours to see if they're interested in having restrictive covenants placed on their property to both benefit themselves and to help their neighbours regarding future development of the community, the uptake has actually been very strong," said Tony Morris, a resident helping to lead the initiative. He said it's interesting to see more communities turn to restrictive covenants as a solution — especially in neighbourhoods that are further out from inner-city Calgary. For his community, it's all about certainty over the future of their streets, "without having the developer community really kind of drive that agenda."
Eliot Tretter, an associate professor in geography at the University of Calgary, said he finds the movement fascinating. He specializes in the history of restrictive covenants. Tretter said he doesn't see this movement having a big impact on the ability to build more housing supply in Calgary, since adding a restrictive covenant is a costly and complex process that most people likely wouldn't want to go through. But for him, there are bigger concerns at hand.
"There's no form of private restriction that is inclusionary.... Why don't we want inclusive communities? What is driving that?""That is something that is maybe more troubling and has longer impacts on the way in which we deal with housing … and how people get housed and how we build our neighbourhoods," said Tretter.
In a statement, the City of Calgary says it doesn't enforce or determine the validity of restrictive covenants. Instead, they're private civil matters that are to be dealt with between the landowners subject to the agreement.
Marble said to get a restrictive covenant removed, all parties who have signed the agreement would have to agree to do so. Or someone could file a court application, arguing that the covenant is no longer enforceable "because people have stopped following it, people have stopped complying with it or it's somehow contrary to the public interest." CBC Sept 23
Performance Standards to Guide the Design of MidRise Buildings A comprehensive discussion of the design of mid-rise buildings in a manner appropriate to the Avenues. City of Toronto May 2010/2016
How to read a Toronto Zoning Bylaw. Still relevant information from elevature, July 30, 2012
So you want to follow a city council meeting, but you don't know all the rules and procedures? We have you covered. From Torontoist, Nov 2, 2015
Developers to play advisory role in group overseeing Doug Ford’s new conservation authority rules January 14, 2021 A month after the province brought in controversial changes to the Conservation Authorities Act, it has put together a working group to implement the new rules, giving developers a key advisory role.
Paris agrees to turn Champs-Élysées into 'extraordinary garden' , Jan 10, 2021 Mayor Anne Hidalgo said the planned work, unveiled in 2019 by local community leaders and businesses, would turn the 1.9 km (1.2 mile) stretch of central Paris into “an extraordinary garden”.
The City’s Bill 108 website is now live here
When Bill 108 and associated regulations come into force, it will affect the planning and financial tools to support new development in communities across Toronto that the City uses to provide:
parks
recreation centres
childcare centres
libraries
subsidized housing
paramedic services and
other community infrastructure.
The Toronto Star, May 11, 2019 Ford government housing Bill 108 could leave developers paying less, Toronto communities with fewer benefits
Globe and Mail, March 11, 2019 Density does not have to equal towers, and according to new research by Ryerson University’s Centre for Urban Research and Land Development all the growth in housing construction the province needs to support both population growth and affordability goals could be met by rezoning areas near transit to support “gentle density,” missing-middle projects.
Globe and Mail, October 19, 2018 There was a time when Toronto worked as an exemplar of city building and municipal governance. Toronto was looked to as a model of metropolitan government and urban planning. But now a shortsighted, buck-a-beer outlook has replaced its breadth of vision.
spacing Toronto, August 20, 2018 Premier Doug Ford’s pledge to upload the subway system will become the Brexit of Toronto politics: a promise balanced on the most dubious of mandates, barely scrutinized during the election and certain to deliver administrative chaos, political conflict and planning gridlock for years to come.
NOW, August 2, 2018 Former mayor David Miller calls out Doug Ford's assault on Toronto council: "The reason Ford has so dramatically interfered with the city's municipal election is crass politics – he wants to get rid of people he doesn’t like"
National Post, July 31, 2018 Ontario Premier Doug Ford’s plan to cut Toronto’s city council from 47 to 25 wards, and to cancel regional elections outside of Toronto, has attracted strong opposition. It threatens to create what critics call a state of “civic chaos” because, if passed, The Better Local Government Act would take effect before the upcoming municipal election this October.
Toronto Storeys, March 14, 2018 Young families have built up a once-neglected neighbourhood. They somewhat gentrified it. They beautified it. They increased its value. Now they believe their efforts — and neighbourhood — are about to be thwarted by a meat-packing plant. Other articles are other link1, and other link2,
The Toronto Star, March 12, 2018 If the city continues on its current financial course, it will face a massive $1.42 billion budget gap in just five years, warns a new report from the city’s top bureaucrat.
The Toronto Star, March 5, 2018 Waterfront Toronto’s eagerness to sign a deal with a Google sister company has alarmed experts who warn cities are easy prey for Big Tech and its unquenchable thirst for data.
Canadian & Consulting Engineer, October 2, 2017 Great Gulf acquiring Mirvish Gehry towers project in Toronto. The development will comprise two towers of 82 and 92 storeys anchored by a multi-level podium.
CBCNews Calgary, September 30, 2017 Flexible zoning is being contemplated in Calgary. Rules around what goes where could boost residential living in the core and bring more business to communities.
CBCNews Toronto, September 22, updated October 5, 2017 A neighbourhood group in north Toronto is organizing a yard sale on Saturday hoping to raise the tens of thousands of dollars it needs to help pay for its three-year fight against a proposed rental development in the area.
Globe and Mail Editorial, September 1, 2017. How density makes for a successful city and why residents and developers must find a happy medium between extremes.
Alex Bozikovic, The Globe and Mail's architecture critic August 29th. A discussion of NIMBY-ism vs the reality of population growth in Toronto. Contains links to other relevant articles.